I've been wearing gel eyeliner for a couple years now. In my opinion, pencil liner can't even compare to gel. I will never go back.
As I was running out of the last brand of liner that I used, I decided to see what other brands were out there. I discovered that Loose Lips NY had a waterproof gel eyeliner. I've tried products from Loose Lips in the past, such as the brow quad and the mineral foundation. I was quite pleased with those products so I decided to give their gel liner a try.
The Indelible Gel Eyeliner arrived on Monday and after two days of wearing it, I love it! It goes on super easy with the use of the mini deluxe fluff brush. It stays on really well and it doesn't come off till I want it to. I decided to try my regular makeup remover before my waterproof makeup remover and the regular worked perfect. I love the color I chose, magnetism. Its a black color with some very faint gold specks.
I would highly recommend gel liner to all that wear eye liner, and at $20, the Indelible Gel Eyeliner is a perfect way to get started. Right now they are offering free shipping with the code juneship through 6/20 on orders over $15. Order here, and don't forget the brush!